Pick-Up In Shop

1
2
3
4
  1. Order Type
  2. Add To Cart
  3. Review Cart
  4. Checkout

Jack Skellington Jumbleberry Pie

Jack Skellington Jumbleberry Pie In-store Pickup

Our amazing Jack Skellington Jumbleberry pie is perfect for Halloween!  Jumbleberry is a mix of blueberry, blackberry, strawberry and raspberry.  

 

1 Dozen Halloween Cupcakes

1 Dozen Halloween Cupcakes In-store Pickup

Wickedly fun and delicious Halloween cupcakes. 3 Red Velvet, 3 Extreme Vanilla Bean, 3 Pumpkin and 3 Triple Chocolate topped with adorably frightening edible toppers.  

Halloween Sugar Cookie Platter

Halloween Sugar Cookie Platter In-store Pickup

Our Halloween sugar cookies are perfect for a gift or a spooky gathering with friends!  10 delicious sugar cookies wrapped and ready to go on a platter.

1 Dozen "Chocolate Lovers" Cupcakes

1 Dozen "Chocolate Lovers" Cupcakes In-store Pickup

Our Chocolate Lover's dozen is a collection of 3 Triple Chocolate, 3 German Chocolate, 3 Pretty Please with a Cherry on Top, and 3 Dippity Do Da (Chocolate cake, vanilla buttercream, topped with a chocolate shell and sprinkles).

1 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes

1 Dozen Assorted Cupcakes In-store Pickup

Our Assorted dozen is a hand-picked assortment fresh from our case and ready to go.

Special flavor requests are welcomed but not guaranteed since some flavors are seasonal, may use seasonal ingredients or require several days notice to prepare. We will do our best to accommodate your request but may need to make substitutions.

9 Inch Banana Cream Pie

9 Inch Banana Cream Pie In-store Pickup

Our Banana Cream Pie comes in our classic, flakey crust. Delicious banana pudding made from scratch, layered with bananas and fresh whipped cream on top!

from $ 25.00

9 inch Chocolate Cream Pie

9 inch Chocolate Cream Pie In-store Pickup

Our Chocolate Cream pie comes in our classic, flakey crust...topped with fresh whipped cream and chocolate curls.

from $ 25.00

9 inch Coconut Cream Pie

9 inch Coconut Cream Pie In-store Pickup

Our Coconut Cream pie comes in our classic, flakey crust...topped with fresh whipped cream and toasted coconut.

from $ 25.00

9 inch Cherry Pie

9 inch Cherry Pie In-store Pickup

Classic cherry pie with a hint of almond.

 

from $ 24.00

9 inch Coconut Chess Pie

9 inch Coconut Chess Pie In-store Pickup

Toasted coconut custard with a chocolate ganache in our delicious pie crust, topped with more toasted coconut.

9 inch Dutch Apple Pie

9 inch Dutch Apple Pie In-store Pickup

An apple medley roasted with warm spices and topped with scrumptious crumb topping.

from $ 23.00

9 inch Hoosier Daddy Pie

9 inch Hoosier Daddy Pie In-store Pickup

Decadent brown sugar custard filling rests in a crunchy, slightly salty oatmeal cookie crust.

9 inch Jumbleberry Pie

9 inch Jumbleberry Pie In-store Pickup

A medley of strawberries, blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries with a hint of citrus under a beautifully decorative crust.

from $ 25.00

9 inch Lemon Chess Pie

9 inch Lemon Chess Pie In-store Pickup

Imagine a lemon bar pie. Fresh bright lemon gives slight tartness to this custard pie.

from $ 20.00

9 inch Lemon Meringue Pie

9 inch Lemon Meringue Pie In-store Pickup

Delicious lemon filling in our classic crust, topped with meringue.